q-perspectival-partition.sheaf-map

{
 "schema_version": 1,
 "artifact_type": "argument_fabric_source_map",
 "question_id": "q:perspectival-partition",
 "source_packet_id": "ip:perspectival-partition-sheaf-gluing",
 "claim_packet": "content/information-packets/perspectival-partition-sheaf-gluing-claims.json",
 "generated_by": "codex",
 "source_role": "formal_constraint",
 "central_reading": "All theories of consciousness face the same gate: they need a law Λ that maps manifestation or organization into exclusive phenomenal domains. The universalization debate was a special case of this deeper problem. The sheaf-theoretic gluing theorem provides an exact formal warning: local coherence does not entail global unifiability.",
 "nnexpr_mappings": [
  {
   "claim_id": "cl:sheaf-local-coherence-not-global",
   "source_span_id": "span:checkpoint-9-globj",
   "quoted_anchor": "local coherence does not entail global unifiability",
   "nn_expr": "virodha(local_agreement,global_section)",
   "parse_status": "invalid",
   "tradition_scope": "cross_tradition",
   "evidence_dimension": "formal",
   "pramana": "anumana",
   "nyaya_reading": {
    "paksa": "phenomenal field",
    "hetu": "local fields lack phenomenal overlap",
    "sadhya": "shared character does not entail one global field",
    "vyapti": "Where local data agrees on empty overlaps, no global section follows."
   },
   "argument_role": "universal_constraint",
   "targets": [
    "cand:siva-decombination",
    "cand:naturalist-emergent",
    "crux:local-to-global-gluing"
   ],
   "gate_outcome": "needs_review",
   "fallacies_flagged": [
    {
     "type": "savyabhicara",
     "severity": "weak",
     "reason": "NNExpr virodha operator not in grammar; parsed as claim without formal/bridge status"
    }
   ],
   "falsifier": "Show that phenomenal fields do overlap in a non-empty self-presence that constitutes a genuine global section."
  },
  {
   "claim_id": "cl:privacy-not-a-positive-boundary",
   "source_span_id": "span:checkpoint-11-privacy",
   "quoted_anchor": "phenomenal separation need not appear as a positive boundary",
   "nn_expr": "sambandha(exclusion,absence_of_co-presence)",
   "parse_status": "invalid",
   "tradition_scope": "cross_tradition",
   "evidence_dimension": "phenomenological",
   "pramana": "pratyaksa",
   "nyaya_reading": {
    "paksa": "phenomenal exclusion",
    "hetu": "other experiences are not presented as bounded objects",
    "sadhya": "exclusion can be privative",
    "vyapti": "Where no boundary appears, separation may still obtain as absence of co-presence."
   },
   "argument_role": "attack_on_absorpt_boundary_argument",
   "targets": [
    "cand:siva-decombination",
    "crux:boundary-introspection-invalid"
   ],
   "gate_outcome": "accepted",
   "fallacies_flagged": [],
   "candidate_under_test": "cand:siva-decombination"
  },
  {
   "claim_id": "cl:all-theories-same-gate",
   "source_span_id": "span:checkpoint-28-bind",
   "quoted_anchor": "Every theory reaches the same gate",
   "nn_expr": "vyapti(every_theory,lambda_missing)",
   "parse_status": "invalid",
   "tradition_scope": "cross_tradition",
   "evidence_dimension": "formal",
   "pramana": "anumana",
   "nyaya_reading": {
    "paksa": "theories of consciousness",
    "hetu": "all can be expressed as {X → Λ → Dᵢ}",
    "sadhya": "Λ is the common missing object",
    "vyapti": "Where every theory requires an unexplained function, that function is the shared gap."
   },
   "argument_role": "metaclaim",
   "targets": [
    "cand:naturalist-emergent",
    "cand:siva-decombination",
    "cand:buddhist-stream",
    "cand:nyaya-plural-substances",
    "cand:neutral-monist",
    "crux:the-law-lambda"
   ],
   "gate_outcome": "accepted",
   "fallacies_flagged": [],
   "candidate_under_test": "crux:the-law-lambda"
  }
 ],
 "argument_edges": [
  {
   "edge_id": "edge:sheaf-gluing-pressures-pratyabhijna",
   "source": "cl:sheaf-local-coherence-not-global",
   "target": "cand:siva-decombination",
   "edge_type": "attacks",
   "str