q-brain-if-consciousness-fundamental.web-map

{
 "schema_version": 1,
 "artifact_type": "argument_fabric_source_map",
 "question_id": "q:brain-if-consciousness-fundamental",
 "source_packet_id": "ip:q17-brain-role-web-claims",
 "claim_packet": "content/information-packets/q17-brain-role-web-claims.json",
 "generated_by": "codex_web_scholarly_review",
 "source_role": "contention_benchmark_evidence_layer",
 "candidate_under_test": "all",
 "central_reading": "The strongest current source-backed answer is not that the brain produces consciousness or that idealism is proved. The graph should say that predictive-processing/interface accounts currently have the best mechanism for mapping neural structure to phenomenological structure, filter accounts remain live but need operational details, and appearance-only idealism remains live only if it can preserve the predictive utility of neuroscience.",
 "nnexpr_mappings": [
  {
   "claim_id": "cl:josipovic-nda-intrinsic-extrinsic-network-correlates",
   "source_span_id": "span:josipovic-2014-nda-networks",
   "quoted_anchor": "nondual awareness practice modulates intrinsic/extrinsic brain networks",
   "nn_expr": "sambandha(nondual_awareness,brain_network_modulation)",
   "parse_status": "parsed",
   "tradition_scope": "nondual_neuroscience",
   "evidence_dimension": "empirical",
   "pramana": "pratyaksa",
   "nyaya_reading": {
    "paksa": "nondual awareness",
    "hetu": "reported NDA is associated with network-level neural modulation",
    "sadhya": "brain-role theories must explain lawful brain-experience coupling",
    "vyapti": "Where a phenomenological state has reliable neural modulation, a viable theory must explain the direction and specificity of that coupling."
   },
   "argument_role": "support",
   "targets": [
    "cand:brain-as-interface-generative-model",
    "crux:neural-correlation-direction"
   ],
   "gate_outcome": "accepted",
   "fallacies_flagged": [
    {
     "type": "asiddha",
     "severity": "weak",
     "reason": "The neural correlation is established as a constraint, not as production or filtering."
    }
   ],
   "falsifier": "Replicated nondual-awareness protocols under adequate controls show no reliable change in intrinsic/extrinsic network dynamics."
  },
  {
   "claim_id": "cl:josipovic-nda-precuneus-minimal-content",
   "source_span_id": "span:josipovic-2014-precuneus",
   "quoted_anchor": "preliminary precuneus-network candidate for consciousness-as-such reports",
   "nn_expr": "sambandha(minimized_phenomenal_content,precuneus_network)",
   "parse_status": "parsed_but_preliminary",
   "tradition_scope": "nondual_neuroscience",
   "evidence_dimension": "empirical",
   "pramana": "pratyaksa",
   "nyaya_reading": {
    "paksa": "minimal-content nondual awareness",
    "hetu": "preliminary data points to precuneus-network involvement",
    "sadhya": "brain-role theories need network-specific predictions",
    "vyapti": "Where a specific phenomenology maps to a specific network, the theory should expose lesion- and modulation-sensitive expectations."
   },
   "argument_role": "support_with_risk",
   "targets": [
    "cand:brain-as-interface-generative-model",
    "crux:brain-damage-transformation"
   ],
   "gate_outcome": "accepted",
   "fallacies_flagged": [
    {
     "type": "savyabhicara",
     "severity": "moderate",
     "reason": "The source is preliminary; the mapping may not generalize across practices or reports."
    }
   ],
   "falsifier": "Higher-powered studies find that minimized-content nondual awareness has no reproducible relation to precuneus-network dynamics."
  },
  {
   "claim_id": "cl:hohwy-seth-pp-ncc-principled-foundation",
   "source_span_id": "span:hohwy-seth-2020-pp-ncc",
   "quoted_anchor": "predictive processing gives NCC search a systematic foundation",
   "nn_expr": "vyapti(predictive_processing,neural_phenomenological_mapping)",
   "parse_status": "parsed",
   "tradition_scope": "predictive_processing",
   "evidence_dimension": "empirical",
   "pramana": "anumana",
   "